top of page
Search

Why Do I Play Well In Football Training But Struggle In Matches?

Writer: Ashley Lewis
Ashley Lewis
Nov 10
7 min read

It’s a typical weekday evening football training session, and you're feeling brilliant and playing with confidence!


Your touch is sharp, you’re seeing passes early, you’re trying things and you feel like the player you know you can be.


Then matchday arrives, and suddenly everything feels just a little bit more sped up.


You take an extra touch you wouldn’t normally take, play a safe pass instead of turning, hesitate before a challenge or start thinking about mistakes before they’ve even happened - and by the end of the game, you’re wondering why the version of you from training seems to disappear as soon as there’s a result, a crowd, coaches watching or something at stake.


If that sounds familiar, you’re definitely not alone!


I see this with players who are technically capable and look confident in training, but struggle to show the same freedom during matches.


The important thing is that it doesn’t automatically mean you’re a 'bad match player' or that your football somehow stops working at the weekend.


Your ability hasn’t disappeared - the environment has changed!

That’s the main idea I’d keep in mind when trying to understand why you play well in football training but struggle in matches.



Football players walking onto an artificial pitch before a match, highlighting teamwork and preparation for grassroots football in Bournemouth.


So Then - Why Do I Play Well In Football Training But Struggle In Matches?

Training usually gives you more information, more repetition and more chances to reset over the space of (typically) an hour or an hour and a half.


You may already know what the exercise is trying to develop...

You know where the ball’s likely to come from, who you’re working with and what you’re expected to do - - and if you make a mistake? there’s often another ball coming within a few seconds.


Matches on the other hand are messier.


You don’t know exactly what the opponent’s going to do, how much space you’ll have or whether your next involvement will come in ten seconds or ten minutes.


Your decisions have consequences too... i.e. lose the ball in training and the practice carries on, but lose it near your own penalty area and it can suddenly feel a lot more daunting and high-pressured!


That difference can make players more cautious even when their technical ability hasn’t changed.


In training, you might turn because you see the space, but in a match, you might notice the same space but also think about what happens if you lose the ball there - and it's here in this moment where that extra thought is often where hesitation begins.



Pressure Can Make Football Feel Faster Than It Actually Is

One of the biggest things pressure changes is your perception of time.


When you’re relaxed, you can scan, receive the ball and make a decision without thinking too much about the process - but when you’re nervous, every action can suddenly feel urgent.


You start trying to solve the next three things at once...


Where’s the defender?

What if I lose it?

Should I pass?

Is the coach watching?

Was that teammate asking for the ball?

What if I make the same mistake again?


By the time the ball arrives, your attention isn’t only on the football anymore.


This is why some players who look very composed in an unopposed or familiar training exercise can suddenly rush when pressure starts to increase.

The technique may still be there... the mind is just much busier!


If this happens most when you’re receiving the ball, my article on why you panic when you get the ball in football goes into that specific situation in more detail.


Finally, I just wanted to end this section by saying that the same thing happens to coaches sometimes too! The amount of times I've overplanned a session, began to deliver it, question myself internally and then look at the time and see that I'm running out of time to get the points across etc.

It happens to us too!



Footballer in a green bib controlling the ball under pressure from a defender, showing skills developed through 1to1 football practice in Poole.


You Might Be Trying Too Hard To Have A Good Game

This sounds strange, but sometimes the desire to play well is exactly what makes a player tighten up.


You’ve been good in training all week, so naturally, you'll want to prove it in the match.


You may want your coach(es) to notice as well as have your teammates to trust you - and you may want to avoid being substituted (and it's only human to try to avoid any potential moments where you may be criticised).


Before long though, every touch starts feeling like a judgement.


Instead of playing to the situation in front of you, you’re judging what each action says about your whole performance.


A misplaced pass isn’t just a misplaced pass anymore... it becomes 'I’m having a bad game'.


Then the next time you get the ball, you’re trying to make up for the previous mistake as well as deal with the current situation - and that’s a lot of pressure to place on one touch.


I’d rather a player focus on the next useful action... Win the ball back or show for a pass or track the runner or Communicate - or just simply make the simple pass if it’s the right one.


A match is made up of hundreds of small moments... Remember, you don’t need every one of them to prove you’re playing well.



Make Training Feel More Like The Problem You Have In Matches

If you only struggle once the pressure, pace or unpredictability increases, then your training needs to include those things too.


Now that doesn’t mean that every session has to be chaotic or brutally difficult - it means gradually adding the parts of matchday that change your behaviour.


If you’re comfortable receiving the ball with no opponent nearby, then add a defender.

If you’re fine when you’ve got unlimited time, reduce the space.

If you make good decisions in a predictable drill, then give yourself more than one possible option so you’ve actually got to read the situation.


You can also practise starting from moments that make you nervous...


Receiving with your back to goal, taking a first touch while somebody closes you down, defending a one-to-one, finishing after a mistake or playing a small-sided game where possession changes quickly.


The aim of this is to make those situations familiar enough that they don’t feel completely new on matchday.


This is something I use a lot in my one-to-one football coaching sessions, because I can control how much pressure a player faces and build it up around the exact situations they’re finding difficult.



Female footballer in a pink shirt preparing to pass the ball during a match, demonstrating passing technique and awareness on the pitch.


Give Yourself A Small Matchday Plan

One thing I like for players who overthink matches is to make the game smaller... i.e. break it down into manageable chunks.


Don’t go into it trying to 'play well for 90 minutes'.

That’s a very vague goal, difficult to actually control and it gives you far too much to judge yourself on.


Instead, choose two or three things you want to keep coming back to... here's some examples:


Scan before the ball arrives - Give yourself a picture of what’s around you before you receive it.


Keep your first few actions simple - You don’t need to force something spectacular to prove you’re confident.


Stay involved after a mistake - Make yourself available again rather than disappearing from the game.


Those aren’t rules for how you have to play - they’re simple reference points you can return to when the match starts feeling noisy in your head.


You can add different ones depending on your position or what you’re working on, but I’d keep the list relatively short (a bit like coaches have to when adding in their coaching points to their plans) 😂



Don’t Judge The Match From Your Worst Moment

Players are often much harsher on themselves after matches than they are after training.


You might complete twenty perfectly timed actions and then spend the journey home thinking about the one pass you gave away!


So that can make the performance gap between training and matches feel a lot bigger than it actually is.


After the game, try to review what happened rather than simply deciding whether you were 'good' or 'bad'.


Self-reflect and ask yourself questions like...

  • What did you do well?

  • When did you feel most comfortable?

  • When did you start rushing?

  • Was there a particular situation that changed your confidence?

  • Did you stop asking for the ball after a mistake?


Because those questions give you something you can use in training - whereas, a general conclusion like 'I’m just better in training' doesn’t tell you what to work on...

A specific conclusion like 'I stopped scanning once I became nervous' or 'I rushed every time somebody pressed me from behind' does.


That’s how you turn a frustrating match into information - rather than evidence that you can’t perform.



Football resting on training bibs beside an artificial pitch, with players training in the background, reflecting grassroots football in Christchurch.


Sometimes The Main Difference Is Confidence

There are times when the technical side isn’t the biggest problem at all.


You can already perform the skill (you’ve shown that repeatedly in training). The bigger challenge is trusting yourself enough to use it when the situation matters.


That’s why confidence work shouldn’t be treated as completely separate from football coaching.


How you respond to mistakes, how much you compare yourself with teammates, whether you feel you belong at the level you’re playing and how you speak to yourself during difficult moments can all affect what your football looks like.


If that side of the game sounds familiar, then my Coping With Confidence And Self-Doubt For Footballers eBook goes much deeper into areas such as negative self-talk, anxiety, imposter syndrome and rebuilding confidence.


Cover of Coping with Confidence and Self-Doubt for Footballers by Ashley Lewis, a Pitch & Prep guide to football confidence and mindset.

I’ve also written about developing a positive mindset for football if you want somewhere else to start.



The Aim Isn’t To Become A Different Player On Matchday

If you play freely in training, there’s already evidence that the ability is there.


You’re not trying to invent a completely new version of yourself for matches - you’re trying to make the gap between the two environments smaller.


That might mean practising with more realistic pressure, simplifying your matchday focus, learning to recover more quickly from mistakes or becoming more comfortable with the fact that matches will never feel as controlled as a training exercise.


Some nerves are normal.


The goal isn’t to feel absolutely nothing when the whistle goes... it’s to stop those feelings changing your decisions so much that you no longer recognise your own game.


Keep getting involved, keep asking for the ball and keep making decisions.


If and when something goes wrong, then let the next action belong to the next moment rather than the previous one.


If you’d like some individual help with confidence, decision-making or transferring what you do in training into matches, I work with players around Bournemouth, Poole, Christchurch, New Milton and surrounding areas through Pitch & Prep.


You can find out more about my one-to-one football coaching here, or if confidence, self-doubt and overthinking are some of the biggest things holding your game back, I’ve created resources specifically to help with those areas too.


Pitch & Prep football guides by Ashley Lewis covering football nutrition, confidence, mindset and training, including The Football Fuel Guide.


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page